Unsure whether to pass payment processing fees directly to your patients? Your decision should be informed by the total financial impact to your practice and how interactions might change for your patients and team.
CDA’s Endorsed Services partner, Best Card, shares four steps to evaluate payment providers and decide if surcharging is the right fit.
Step 1: Conduct a cost review.
Before deciding whether to surcharge, get a clear view of your existing processing costs. Gather recent statements and consider requesting a comparison of your current terms, alternative pricing and surcharging options from your provider.
Next, calculate your practice’s effective rate to have an apples-to-apples basis for comparison. Divide the total amount of fees paid by the total amount run in card sales to find your effective rate.
For example, the average CDA member who used Best Card for processing in 2025 paid 2.29% with a transparent rate and 0.96% with surcharge. By comparison, offices using competing processors paid an average of 3.56%.
Step 2: Understand the rules for debit cards, Medicare and Medicaid.
Surcharging can shift some payment costs to patients, but it can’t make all those costs disappear or offset your entire processing bill.
Federal law and card brand regulations (i.e., Visa or Mastercard) prohibit surcharges on debit and prepaid cards, even if a patient does not enter a PIN or a practice runs that debit card as credit. This means your practice will be responsible for the fees on these types of transactions. Visa’s merchant guidance and Mastercard’s surcharge rules explain these restrictions.
When it comes to Medicare and Medicaid, a dental office generally cannot charge for covered services beyond what the program’s fee schedule allows. Adding a credit card fee can push the patient’s total payment above the approved amount, which will violate the provider’s Medicare agreement and applicable law.
When choosing a payment provider, ask for a written breakdown of which costs patients would pay and which costs your practice would retain. Be wary if a provider claims that they will eliminate all processing costs for your practice by surcharging debit cards. These noncompliant surcharging options can incur significant fines.
Step 3: Review the payment provider’s specific rules.
Card providers also have their own rules for how practices can implement surcharging. For example, Visa limits surcharges to the applicable merchant discount rate or 3%, whichever is lower. It also requires specific disclosures and receipt information. Therefore, quoted surcharge amounts from card providers may not necessarily apply to your practice.
Step 4: Prepare for point-of-payment conversation.
The financial benefit of passing off card fees to patients has to be weighed against patient satisfaction, collection timing and staff workload.
California state laws require that the entire price is clearly disclosed to customers. If a procedure is $500, you can’t say the cost is “$500 plus a 3% surcharge for credit cards.” Instead, you must say, “The full price is $515.00 when paid by credit card.” California’s attorney general’s office provides guidance on the SB478 Hidden Fee legislation.
Even when the fee is permitted and properly disclosed, patients may have questions about why it was added and what other payment options are available. Dental office team members should be prepared to explain the financial policy to the patient before payment, especially for larger treatment balances. Ensure staff can answer questions consistently and offer alternative payment options that do not carry a surcharge.
CDA member support and resources
CDA’s specialized experts have developed tools to help members navigate practice operational decision-making and managing overhead expenses. Downloadable resources include a checklist for evaluating merchant credit card processors and a credit card authorization form for automating payments.
Members can also receive free, no-obligation savings analyses by submitting a short form to Best Card. Their experts can break down current pricing and uncover savings opportunities with and without surcharging.
For a deeper dive into the pros, cons and regulations of surcharging credit cards for dental practices, register for Best Card’s upcoming webinar set for Friday, Jan. 22.

