05/14/2018

FTC complaint alleges collusion among top dental suppliers


Benco Dental Supply Company, Henry Schein Inc. and Patterson Companies Inc. were named in a complaint filed recently by the Federal Trade Commission. The FTC alleges that the three dental suppliers — the nation’s largest — violated federal antitrust laws by conspiring to refuse to provide discounts to buying groups representing solo and small-group dental practices.

“The alleged agreement among Benco, HenrySchein and Patterson deprived independent dentists of the benefits of participating in buying groups that purchase dental supplies from national, full-service distributors,” the FTC stated in a news release.

The complaint has garnered national media attention and negatively impacted the share pricesof publicly traded Patterson and Henry Schein shortly after the FTC’s announcement. An article in the Minneapolis Star Tribune reported, “The FTC allegations come as the companies battle similar claims in a spate of private antitrust lawsuits filed since 2012.”

The three companies collectively control more than 85 percent of the $10 billion in dental products and services sold by distributors annually in the U.S., according to the FTC. All three companies have publicly denied the charges and have vowed to fight the matter. Henry Schein in a news release stated, “Henry Schein has a long history of serving customers with integrity and honesty, and we have earned our reputation for doing business the right way.” Patterson called the allegations “meritless.”

After reviewing the evidence, including emails and other internal and inter-firm communications dating as early as 2012, the FTC charged that “The Distributors feared that Buying Groups would drive down prices and threaten their profit margins, and they sought to prevent independent dentists from obtaining greater bargaining power through Buying Groups.”

Entering into a horizontal agreement to restrain price competition is a violation of Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act, which prohibits unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce. By entering into such an agreement, Benco, Henry Schein and Patterson distorted prices, “unreasonably reduced output of dental products to dental buying groups” and “eliminated or reduced the competitive bidding process for sales to these buying groups,” the FTC complaint alleges.

Benco is also charged separately for inviting the nation’s fourth largest dental supply company to join the agreement to stop providing discounts to buying groups, but the company declined to participate.

An administrative trial is scheduled to begin in October.

CDA will update members about the FTC’s antitrust case as information becomes available.



Related Items

When CDA’s subsidiary The Dentists Service Company launched the TDSC Marketplace last year, it was with a bold mission: to deliver practice-changing savings on dental supplies to CDA members. Learn more about this new member benefit at CDA Presents The Art and Science of Dentistry in Anaheim May 17–19. Stop by CDA’s Member Benefits Center in booth 1102 of the convention exhibit hall, where the Marketplace team will showcase the site and help attendees “test drive” features.

Also known as “the law of the vital few,” the Pareto principle is often expressed as 80 percent of effects coming from 20 percent of causes. You’ve likely observed this phenomenon in your own practice — whether it’s a large percentage of revenue coming from a relatively small number of procedures or a high percentage of new patients coming in from one of your many marketing efforts. However, one of the areas in which the Pareto principle is most evident is in your dental supply budget.

With a growing diversity in practice models, including an increase in dentists working as employees or contractors and a decrease in practice ownership, there is no denying that the business challenges for dentists across the nation continue to grow as well. Feeling the combined impacts of dental benefit pressures, growing market competition and the rapid expansion of large group practices, CDA members voiced a need for more control.

Topics
Top